Herbicide Treatment | Rate (g ai ha−1) | Black Bean | White Bean | Adzuki Bean | Kidney Bean | ||||||||
Plant Stand |
|
|
|
|
|
| % |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Untreated check |
| 100 | ab | Z | 100 | a | Z | 100 | a | Z | 100 | a | Z |
Dimethenamid-p | 220 | 123 | a | Z | 108 | a | Z | 100 | a | Z | 105 | a | Z |
Dimethenamid-p | 440 | 121 | a | Z | 98 | a | YZ | 94 | a | YZ | 81 | ab | Y |
Saflufenacil | 25 | 59 | c | Y | 72 | a | YZ | 99 | a | Z | 99 | ab | Z |
Saflufenacil | 50 | 47 | c | Y | 33 | b | Y | 90 | a | Z | 77 | ab | Z |
Dimethenamid-p/saflufenacil | 220 + 25 | 65 | bc | Y | 77 | a | YZ | 91 | a | YZ | 102 | a | Z |
Dimethenamid-p/saflufenacil | 440 + 50 | 47 | c | YZ | 30 | b | Y | 69 | a | Z | 62 | b | Z |
Shoot Dry Weight |
|
|
|
|
|
| % |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Untreated check |
| 100 | a | Z | 100 | ab | Z | 100 | a | Z | 100 | a | Z |
Dimethenamid-p | 220 | 117 | a | Z | 113 | a | Z | 98 | a | Z | 98 | a | Z |
Dimethenamid-p | 440 | 107 | a | Z | 104 | ab | Z | 87 | ab | Z | 84 | ab | Z |
Saflufenacil | 25 | 55 | b | Y | 59 | c | Y | 100 | a | Z | 86 | ab | YZ |
Saflufenacil | 50 | 39 | b | Y | 26 | d | Y | 81 | ab | Z | 74 | ab | Z |
Dimethenamid-p/saflufenacil | 220 + 25 | 62 | b | Z | 71 | bc | Z | 87 | ab | Z | 90 | ab | Z |
Dimethenamid-p/saflufenacil | 440 + 50 | 37 | b | YZ | 19 | d | Y | 54 | b | Z | 58 | b | Z |
Height |
|
|
|
|
|
| % |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Untreated check |
| 100 | a | Z | 100 | ab | Z | 100 | ab | Z | 100 | a | Z |
Dimethenamid-p | 220 | 100 | a | Z | 104 | ab | Z | 103 | ab | Z | 102 | a | Z |
Dimethenamid-p | 440 | 107 | a | Z | 108 | a | Z | 103 | ab | Z | 102 | a | Z |
Saflufenacil | 25 | 93 | a | Z | 91 | ab | Z | 105 | a | Z | 98 | a | Z |
Saflufenacil | 50 | 74 | b | XY | 59 | c | X | 94 | ab | Z | 90 | a | YZ |
Dimethenamid-p/saflufenacil | 220 + 25 | 95 | a | Z | 87 | b | Z | 102 | ab | Z | 95 | a | Z |
Dimethenamid-p/saflufenacil | 440 + 50 | 69 | b | XY | 52 | c | X | 86 | b | Z | 85 | a | YZ |
Seed Yield |
|
|
|
|
|
| % |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Untreated check |
| 100 | a | Z | 100 | a | Z | 100 | a | Z | 100 | abc | Z |
Dimethenamid-p | 220 | 99 | a | Z | 115 | a | Z | 105 | a | Z | 106 | ab | Z |
Dimethenamid-p | 440 | 101 | a | Z | 113 | a | Z | 107 | a | Z | 115 | a | Z |
Saflufenacil | 25 | 88 | ab | Z | 99 | a | Z | 124 | a | Z | 106 | ab | Z |
Saflufenacil | 50 | 60 | bc | XY | 46 | b | X | 129 | a | Z | 78 | bc | Y |
Dimethenamid-p/saflufenacil | 220 + 25 | 89 | ab | Z | 90 | a | Z | 120 | a | Z | 99 | abc | Z |
Dimethenamid-p/saflufenacil | 440 + 50 | 53 | c | XY | 39 | b | X | 114 | a | Z | 71 | c | Y |