Herbicide Treatment

Rate (g ai ha1)

Black Bean

White Bean

Adzuki Bean

Kidney Bean

Plant Stand

%

Untreated check

100

ab

Z

100

a

Z

100

a

Z

100

a

Z

Dimethenamid-p

220

123

a

Z

108

a

Z

100

a

Z

105

a

Z

Dimethenamid-p

440

121

a

Z

98

a

YZ

94

a

YZ

81

ab

Y

Saflufenacil

25

59

c

Y

72

a

YZ

99

a

Z

99

ab

Z

Saflufenacil

50

47

c

Y

33

b

Y

90

a

Z

77

ab

Z

Dimethenamid-p/saflufenacil

220 + 25

65

bc

Y

77

a

YZ

91

a

YZ

102

a

Z

Dimethenamid-p/saflufenacil

440 + 50

47

c

YZ

30

b

Y

69

a

Z

62

b

Z

Shoot Dry Weight

%

Untreated check

100

a

Z

100

ab

Z

100

a

Z

100

a

Z

Dimethenamid-p

220

117

a

Z

113

a

Z

98

a

Z

98

a

Z

Dimethenamid-p

440

107

a

Z

104

ab

Z

87

ab

Z

84

ab

Z

Saflufenacil

25

55

b

Y

59

c

Y

100

a

Z

86

ab

YZ

Saflufenacil

50

39

b

Y

26

d

Y

81

ab

Z

74

ab

Z

Dimethenamid-p/saflufenacil

220 + 25

62

b

Z

71

bc

Z

87

ab

Z

90

ab

Z

Dimethenamid-p/saflufenacil

440 + 50

37

b

YZ

19

d

Y

54

b

Z

58

b

Z

Height

%

Untreated check

100

a

Z

100

ab

Z

100

ab

Z

100

a

Z

Dimethenamid-p

220

100

a

Z

104

ab

Z

103

ab

Z

102

a

Z

Dimethenamid-p

440

107

a

Z

108

a

Z

103

ab

Z

102

a

Z

Saflufenacil

25

93

a

Z

91

ab

Z

105

a

Z

98

a

Z

Saflufenacil

50

74

b

XY

59

c

X

94

ab

Z

90

a

YZ

Dimethenamid-p/saflufenacil

220 + 25

95

a

Z

87

b

Z

102

ab

Z

95

a

Z

Dimethenamid-p/saflufenacil

440 + 50

69

b

XY

52

c

X

86

b

Z

85

a

YZ

Seed Yield

%

Untreated check

100

a

Z

100

a

Z

100

a

Z

100

abc

Z

Dimethenamid-p

220

99

a

Z

115

a

Z

105

a

Z

106

ab

Z

Dimethenamid-p

440

101

a

Z

113

a

Z

107

a

Z

115

a

Z

Saflufenacil

25

88

ab

Z

99

a

Z

124

a

Z

106

ab

Z

Saflufenacil

50

60

bc

XY

46

b

X

129

a

Z

78

bc

Y

Dimethenamid-p/saflufenacil

220 + 25

89

ab

Z

90

a

Z

120

a

Z

99

abc

Z

Dimethenamid-p/saflufenacil

440 + 50

53

c

XY

39

b

X

114

a

Z

71

c

Y