CG (N = 57)

EG (N = 58)

M

S

M

S

t

p

Pretest

Composition

87.17

9.04

86.60

9.86

.277

.837

Listening

141.19

12.39

139.55

10.23

.663

.175

Reading

147.12

11.82

148.60

11.28

−.585

.657

Translation

44.55

4.46

44.64

4.97

−.092

.658

Oral English

9.40

1.06

9.42

1.12

−.100

.958

Total

429.43

38.77

428.81

37.46

0.163

.968

After the

experiment

Composition

85.21

8.24

89.12

8.32

−2.082

.042*

Listening

143.1

9.45

145.2

9.12

−2.121

.037*

Reading

149.02

10.82

151.210

9.28

−.585

.047*

Translation

45.93

5.75

45.14

5.21

.656

.513

Oral English

9.46

1.32

9.57

1.38

−2.107

.038*

Total

432.72

35.58

440.24

33.31

−6.237

.034*