Dialogic teaching practices are often experienced as: | Monologic teaching practices are often experienced as: |
a learning focused partnership | directive compliance relationship |
open, participatory and collaborative | a one-way transmission of knowledge |
the typical IRE is disrupted with a 4th turn | a typical 3-part IRE structure |
talk is a leverage for deep learning and reasoning | talk for organising students, behaviour and resources |
more dynamic, active and activist | more static and passive |
process orientated – making learning and knowledge public | knowledge driven – ideas often remain invisible |
more students have a voice | more students being silent |
active listening to teachers and peers | teacher centred, directed and mediated |
equitable ways of relating | hierarchical ways of relating |
shared responsibility for learning | students responsible for complying |
more time for students thinking and talking | less time for students thinking and talking |
more opportunities for thinking and talking | less room for negotiation of meaning |
more time for rehearsing and consolidating ideas | “on the run” thinking and articulation of ideas |
students develop from what they are thinking | students trying to guess what is in teachers’ mind |
students positioned as thinkers, theorises, holders of a position | students positioned as followers of instructions and more simply as being correct or incorrect |
making learning and thinking and knowledge accountable | making compliance accountable or prioritised |
more open-ended questioning enabling reasoning, hypothesising and “thinking aloud” | questioning for known answers or more closed questioning |
divergent ideas accepted and valued | having more convergence of ideas |
more democratic | more autocratic |
power and agency being dispersed more equally | having power and agency dominated by the teacher |
time for talk being more equitable – the “floor is shared” | the floor being generally the province of the teacher |