Equation number | Author [Reference] | Simulation time 1 (s) | Simulation time 2 (s) | Simulation time 3 (s) | Simulation time 4 (s) | Mean Simulation time (s) | Relative Computational efficiency |
13 | Ghanbari, Farshad and Rieke [17] | 2.0018 | 2.0018 | 1.9825 | 2.1063 | 2.0231 | 0.3776 |
3 | Buzzelli [16] | 2.0160 | 1.9813 | 2.0708 | 2.1527 | 2.0552 | 0.3836 |
19 | This study | 2.0828 | 2.0082 | 2.0730 | 2.1669 | 2.0827 | 0.3883 |
11 | Haaland [22] | 2.0833 | 2.0080 | 2.2566 | 2.0259 | 2.0935 | 0.3907 |
16 | Brkić [26] | 2.0687 | 2.1409 | 2.1994 | 2.1103 | 2.1298 | 0.3974 |
12 | Manadilli [23] | 2.1511 | 1.9947 | 2.3941 | 2.0287 | 2.1421 | 0.3998 |
18 | Rao and Kumar [27] | 2.2285 | 2.4316 | 2.1779 | 2.0146 | 2.2131 | 0.4130 |
15 | Round [25] | 2.5790 | 2.1902 | 2.2479 | 2.1139 | 2.2828 | 0.4260 |
10 | Sonnad and Goudar [21] | 2.7362 | 2.71272 | 2.7368 | 2.7202 | 2.7264 | 0.5088 |
9 | Shakham [20] | 3.921 | 4.1258 | 4.1667 | 4.1146 | 4.082 | 0.7650 |
6 | Chen [11] | 4.3073 | 4.1367 | 3.9977 | 4.1984 | 4.1601 | 0.7763 |
7 | Barr [19] | 4.5447 | 4.2223 | 4.1907 | 4.3816 | 4.3348 | 0.8090 |
5 | Romeo, Royo and Monzon [9] | 6.0524 | 6.2378 | 6.0786 | 6.0439 | 6.1032 | 1.1390 |
2 | Serghides [15] | 6.0707 | 6.1784 | 6.1017 | 6.1326 | 6.1334 | 1.1447 |
4 | Zigrang and Sylvester [14] | 6.8008 | 6.0883 | 6.9692 | 6.3390 | 6.5493 | 1.2222 |